| Player | Team | Role | Rating | Year | Depth |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jaxton Eck | UNM | MLB | 89 | Senior | starter |
| Austin Brawley | UNM | FS | 84 ▲1 | Senior | starter |
| Kaden Robnett | UNM | C | 83 | Junior | starter |
| Troy Omeire pts/play 0.35 · rec 6 of 34 (18%) · rec yds med 22 | UNM | WR | 82 ▼1 | Senior | depth |
| Scottre Humphrey pts/play 0.15 · carries 57 of 181 (31%) · rush yds med 84 | UNM | HB | 80 ▼1 | Senior | starter |
| Kiefer Sibley pts/play 0.23 · carries 33 of 181 (18%) · rec 4 of 42 (10%) · rush yds med 47 · rec yds med 4 | UNM | HB | 80 | Junior | starter |
| Tavian Combs | UNM | SS | 80 | Senior | depth |
| Cade Keith pts/play 0.80 · rec 10 of 32 (31%) · rec yds med 63 | UNM | TE | 79 | Sophomore | starter |
| Brian Booker | UNM | DT | 78 ▲1 | Senior | starter |
| Jaymar Tasi | UNM | RG | 77 ▼1 | Sophomore | starter |
| Darren Agu | UNM | RE | 77 | Senior | starter |
| Deshaun Buchanan carries 6 of 137 (4%) · rush yds med 12 | UNM | HB | 77 | Junior | depth |
| Frankie Edwards III | UNM | CB | 77 | Junior | starter |
| Jack Layne | UNM | QB | 77 | Senior | depth |
| Ormanie Arnold | UNM | CB | 77 | Senior | starter |
| Shawn Miller | UNM | WR | 76 | Senior | depth |
| Albert Tuakalau | UNM | LE | 75 | Junior | depth |
| Tyler Lawrence | UNM | RT | 75 ▲1 | Junior | starter |
| Will Hicks | UNM | SS | 74 | Junior | depth |
| Eric McClain | UNM | CB | 73 | Junior | depth |
| Miles Williams rec 1 of 17 (6%) · rec yds med 19 | UNM | WR | 73 | Senior | depth |
| Zhaiel Smith rec 4 of 27 (15%) · rec yds med 29 | UNM | WR | 73 | Sophomore | starter |
| Malik Aliane | UNM | LG | 73 ▲1 | Senior | starter |
| Mercury Swaim | UNM | ROLB | 73 ▲1 | Senior | starter |
| Bailen George pts/play 0.03 · rec 9 of 35 (26%) · rec yds med 36 | UNM | WR | 73 ▲10 | Freshman | starter |
| CJ McBean | UNM | FS | 72 | Sophomore | depth |
| DJ Darling rec 2 of 24 (8%) · rec yds med 22 | UNM | WR | 72 | Freshman | starter |
| Kevin Longstreet | UNM | CB | 72 | Junior | depth |
| Michael Kern | UNM | P | 71 ▼6 | Junior | depth |
| Charles Steinkamp | UNM | P | 71 ▼5 | Senior | depth |
| Cameron Mathews pts/play -0.21 · carries 14 of 96 (15%) · rush yds med 21 | UNM | HB | 71 | Freshman | depth |
| Darrion Bowers pts/play 0.05 · carries 13 of 96 (14%) · rush yds med 31 | UNM | HB | 71 | Freshman | depth |
| Dorian Patterson rec 1 of 17 (6%) · rec yds med 6 | UNM | WR | 71 | Freshman | depth |
| Drew Speech | UNM | SS | 71 | Senior | starter |
| Markus Fetcho | UNM | RT | 71 | Sophomore | depth |
| Massiah Mingo rec 2 of 17 (12%) · rec yds med 26 | UNM | WR | 71 | Freshman | depth |
| Clay Martineau | UNM | MLB | 71 ▲2 | Sophomore | starter |
| Elijah Brody | UNM | LE | 70 | Junior | depth |
| Tripp Walsh rec 1 of 17 (6%) · rec yds med 5 | UNM | TE | 70 | Junior | depth |
| Grant Glasgow | UNM | K | 70 ▲2 | Senior | depth |
| Toa Fa'avae pts/play 0.11 · carries 35 of 181 (19%) · rush yds med 31 · pass yds med 85 | UNM | QB | 70 ▲5 | Freshman | starter |
| Luke Moga pts/play 0.11 · carries 6 of 134 (4%) · rush yds med -1 · pass yds med 82 | UNM | QB | 69 ▼1 | Sophomore | depth |
| Abraham Williams | UNM | WR | 69 | Senior | depth |
| Jayden Sheridan | UNM | CB | 69 | Senior | depth |
| Joey Olsen | UNM | TE | 69 | Sophomore | depth |
| John Sierra | UNM | RE | 69 | Sophomore | depth |
| Xavier Slayton | UNM | LE | 69 | Senior | depth |
| Cole Millward | UNM | LT | 69 ▲3 | Junior | starter |
| Jalen Charles | UNM | LE | 68 ▼3 | Sophomore | depth |
| Elvin Harris | UNM | RT | 68 | Junior | depth |
| James Laubstein pts/play 0.81 · carries 12 of 181 (7%) · rush yds med 10 | UNM | QB | 68 | Senior | depth |
| Simon Mapa | UNM | TE | 68 | Senior | depth |
| Joshua Barnes | UNM | FS | 68 ▲1 | Sophomore | depth |
| Nick Romero | UNM | K | 67 ▼1 | Sophomore | depth |
| Cody Thumlert | UNM | RE | 67 | Freshman | depth |
| Jalen McIver | UNM | DT | 67 | Junior | depth |
| Josh Mensah | UNM | CB | 67 | Freshman | depth |
| Jubilee Siitia-Tasi | UNM | RG | 67 | Freshman | depth |
| Kader Diop rec 1 of 10 (10%) · rec yds med 0 | UNM | WR | 67 | Senior | depth |
| Tevin Shaw | UNM | LT | 67 | Senior | depth |
| Deven Dyer | UNM | DT | 66 | Senior | depth |
| Jahmir Torres | UNM | CB | 66 | Sophomore | starter |
| JoJo Matautia | UNM | LG | 66 | Freshman | depth |
| Lincoln Epstein | UNM | TE | 66 | Sophomore | depth |
| C.J. Johnson | UNM | MLB | 65 | Junior | depth |
| Caleb Spitzer | UNM | LT | 65 (launch) | Freshman | depth |
| Marco Beltran Jr. | UNM | FS | 65 | Freshman | depth |
| Max Leeper | UNM | TE | 65 | Freshman | depth |
| Xavier Rivera-Rogers | UNM | CB | 65 | Freshman | depth |
| Chris Gant Jr. | UNM | FS | 64 | Sophomore | depth |
| Hayes Baum | UNM | MLB | 64 | Freshman | depth |
| Ricklan Holmes II | UNM | LOLB | 64 | Freshman | depth |
| Isaiah Roberts | UNM | FB | 63 (launch) | Junior | depth |
| Kendrick Lennon | UNM | LOLB | 63 (launch) | Sophomore | depth |
| Nick Wheeler | UNM | SS | 63 | Freshman | depth |
| Jack Burzynski | UNM | LE | 61 | Freshman | depth |
| Thomas Pettus | UNM | ROLB | 61 | Freshman | depth |
| AJ Robinson | UNM | DT | 60 | Junior | depth |
| Jake Devos | UNM | RE | 60 | Freshman | depth |
| Josh Barrett | UNM | C | 60 (launch) | Freshman | depth |
| Martin Thurman | UNM | LG | 59 (launch) | Freshman | depth |
| Tim Gregg | UNM | RG | 59 (launch) | Freshman | depth |
| Sa'Kylee Woodard | UNM | C | 58 | Sophomore | depth |
| Trent Rocker | UNM | ROLB | 58 | Junior | depth |
| Nick Barber | UNM | DT | 57 | Freshman | depth |
| Brett Karhu | UNM | DL | n/r | starter | |
| Brett Karhu | UNM | DL | n/r | starter |