| Player | Team | Role | Rating | Year | Depth |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chris Reed pts/play 0.45 · rec 11 of 99 (11%) · rec yds med 56 | SHSU | WR | 83 | Senior | starter |
| Grady O'Neill pts/play 0.55 · rec 22 of 99 (22%) · rec yds med 53 | SHSU | WR | 82 | Senior | starter |
| Alton McCaskill pts/play -0.10 · carries 43 of 122 (35%) · rec 9 of 99 (9%) · rush yds med 45 · rec yds med 5 | SHSU | HB | 80 | Senior | starter |
| Josiah Chenault | SHSU | C | 80 | Junior | depth |
| Landan Brown pts/play -0.02 · carries 20 of 122 (16%) · rec 11 of 99 (11%) · rush yds med 19 · rec yds med 15 | SHSU | HB | 79 | Junior | depth |
| Jerrian Parker Jr. pts/play 0.25 · carries 11 of 98 (11%) · rec 6 of 69 (9%) · rush yds med 14 · rec yds med 10 | SHSU | HB | 77 | Junior | depth |
| Justin Terrell | SHSU | DT | 76 | Sophomore | depth |
| Dylan Frazier | SHSU | DT | 75 | Senior | starter |
| Josh Alexander-Felton | SHSU | LE | 75 | Sophomore | starter |
| Kyan Berry-Johnson pts/play 1.05 · rec 10 of 99 (10%) · rec yds med 36 | SHSU | WR | 75 | Sophomore | starter |
| Aviyon Smith-Mack rec 1 of 22 (5%) · rec yds med 3 | SHSU | WR | 74 | Senior | depth |
| Kaleb Mitchell | SHSU | WR | 73 ▼3 | Freshman | depth |
| Ca'lub Holloway | SHSU | LOLB | 73 | Senior | depth |
| Dean Ford | SHSU | MLB | 73 | Sophomore | starter |
| Elijah Groves | SHSU | ROLB | 73 | Freshman | starter |
| Max Whisner rec 6 of 76 (8%) · rec yds med 17 | SHSU | TE | 73 | Senior | starter |
| Tim Burns Jr. pts/play 0.95 · rec 7 of 75 (9%) · rec yds med 63 | SHSU | WR | 73 | Senior | depth |
| Landyn Locke pts/play 0.29 · carries 27 of 122 (22%) · rush yds med 0 · pass yds med 319 | SHSU | QB | 73 ▲3 | Sophomore | starter |
| Darien Jackson | SHSU | DT | 73 ▲7 | Junior | starter |
| Jace Arnold | SHSU | CB | 72 | Junior | starter |
| Jarra Anderson | SHSU | DT | 72 | Junior | depth |
| Tavin Houston | SHSU | P | 72 (launch) | Sophomore | depth |
| Sam Carpenter | SHSU | K | 71 ▼5 | Junior | depth |
| Christian Zachary | SHSU | WR | 71 ▼3 | Sophomore | depth |
| Cal Joseph | SHSU | P | 71 ▼2 | Sophomore | depth |
| Ah'Marion Gaines-Smith carries 3 of 40 (8%) · rush yds med 21 | SHSU | HB | 71 | Senior | depth |
| Brian Bates Jr. | SHSU | MLB | 71 | Junior | starter |
| Brock Stukes | SHSU | LG | 71 | Junior | starter |
| Chauncey Chidi | SHSU | LE | 71 | Senior | depth |
| Tokyo Gordon | SHSU | MLB | 71 | Senior | depth |
| Isaac Sohn | SHSU | LT | 71 ▲1 | Junior | starter |
| Graceson Spann | SHSU | RT | 71 ▲8 | Freshman | starter |
| Cam Todd | SHSU | C | 70 | Senior | depth |
| Darrick Bledsoe III pts/play 0.62 · rec 10 of 75 (13%) · rec yds med 26 | SHSU | WR | 70 | Junior | depth |
| Jayden Fry | SHSU | RE | 70 | Freshman | depth |
| Mike King | SHSU | ROLB | 70 | Sophomore | depth |
| Alijah Cason | SHSU | WR | 69 | Junior | depth |
| Brody Henderson | SHSU | RE | 69 | Sophomore | starter |
| Caesar Magee | SHSU | CB | 69 | Senior | starter |
| Dylan Mann | SHSU | K | 69 (launch) | Senior | depth |
| Ishmel Atkins | SHSU | CB | 69 | Senior | starter |
| She'Fon Boyd | SHSU | DT | 69 | Junior | depth |
| Trey Winfrey | SHSU | DT | 69 (launch) | Senior | depth |
| Uzziah Warmate | SHSU | DT | 69 | Freshman | depth |
| Zo'maryon Bryan | SHSU | LG | 69 | Senior | depth |
| Chris Blair | SHSU | QB | 68 (launch) | Freshman | depth |
| Gabriel Goodwin | SHSU | TE | 68 (launch) | Junior | depth |
| Jaylon Jones | SHSU | FS | 68 | Junior | depth |
| Lyric Smith | SHSU | CB | 68 | Sophomore | depth |
| Tyler Bailey | SHSU | SS | 68 | Senior | starter |
| Railyn Adams | SHSU | FS | 68 ▲2 | Sophomore | starter |
| Brett Holloway pts/play 0.25 · carries 10 of 98 (10%) · rush yds med 6 · pass yds med 0 | SHSU | QB | 67 | Freshman | depth |
| DJ Bailey | SHSU | QB | 67 | Sophomore | depth |
| Elijah Collins | SHSU | RG | 67 | Junior | depth |
| Kamari Maxwell rec 5 of 99 (5%) · rec yds med 22 | SHSU | WR | 67 | Sophomore | depth |
| Stacy Bey | SHSU | LOLB | 67 | Sophomore | depth |
| Myles Joseph | SHSU | LT | 67 ▲3 | Freshman | starter |
| Dravon Wilson | SHSU | CB | 66 | Sophomore | depth |
| Jalyn Stanford | SHSU | SS | 66 | Junior | depth |
| Kaden Winkfield carries 5 of 40 (12%) · rush yds med 21 | SHSU | HB | 66 | Freshman | depth |
| Zion Taylor | SHSU | LE | 66 | Sophomore | depth |
| Denell Nix Jr | SHSU | LT | 66 ▲3 | Sophomore | starter |
| Nico Ottomanelli | SHSU | K | 65 ▼6 | Sophomore | depth |
| Bryen Spaulding | SHSU | RE | 65 | Senior | depth |
| CJ June | SHSU | CB | 65 | Freshman | depth |
| Jeremy Fitzgerald | SHSU | C | 65 (launch) | Freshman | depth |
| Octavius Henderson | SHSU | CB | 65 | Senior | depth |
| R.J. Massey | SHSU | FB | 65 (launch) | Junior | depth |
| Logan Cahill | SHSU | RG | 64 | Sophomore | depth |
| Robert McFarland | SHSU | SS | 64 | Freshman | depth |
| Ty Sexton | SHSU | WR | 64 | Freshman | depth |
| Braylen Wortham | SHSU | FS | 63 | Sophomore | depth |
| Carter Kadow | SHSU | RT | 62 | Sophomore | depth |
| Dre Chambers | SHSU | RT | 62 (launch) | Sophomore | depth |
| Dalvin Johnson Jr. | SHSU | LT | 61 (launch) | Freshman | depth |
| Kyle Bruce | SHSU | TE | 61 (launch) | Freshman | depth |
| Miles Winston | SHSU | ROLB | 61 (launch) | Freshman | depth |
| Zayne Langford | SHSU | LOLB | 61 (launch) | Freshman | depth |
| Cooper Stevens | SHSU | TE | 60 | Sophomore | depth |
| Eli Wallace | SHSU | ROLB | 60 | Junior | depth |
| Kordell Lathan | SHSU | MLB | 60 (launch) | Freshman | depth |
| Joe Warren | SHSU | RG | 58 | Junior | depth |
| Carson Whitington | SHSU | TE | 57 | Senior | depth |
| Tr'e Williams | SHSU | LG | 55 | Freshman | depth |
| Ryan Mallory | SHSU | MLB | 49 | Freshman | depth |
| Landan "Coco" Brown | SHSU | RB | n/r | starter |