| Player | Team | Role | Rating | Year | Depth |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bernock Iya | NMSU | FS | 84 | Senior | depth |
| TK King | NMSU | WR | 81 | Senior | starter |
| Nick Session | NMSU | SS | 81 ▲2 | Senior | starter |
| Sone Aupiu | NMSU | MLB | 80 | Senior | starter |
| Tory Gethers | NMSU | ROLB | 78 | Senior | starter |
| James Jones pts/play 0.12 · carries 57 of 123 (46%) · rec 5 of 79 (6%) · rush yds med 95 · rec yds med 8 | NMSU | HB | 78 ▲1 | Senior | starter |
| Dijon Stanley pts/play -0.13 · carries 13 of 123 (11%) · rec 2 of 79 (3%) · rush yds med 17 · rec yds med 2 | NMSU | HB | 77 | Senior | depth |
| TJ Pride pts/play 0.28 · rec 6 of 56 (11%) · rec yds med 5 | NMSU | WR | 77 | Junior | depth |
| Gabe Peterson | NMSU | LE | 76 | Senior | starter |
| Josiah Charles | NMSU | CB | 76 | Junior | starter |
| Zhakius Thomas | NMSU | LE | 76 | Junior | depth |
| Isaiah Rudison carries 3 of 40 (8%) · rush yds med 18 | NMSU | HB | 75 | Senior | depth |
| Kaian Roberts-Day | NMSU | DT | 75 | Senior | depth |
| Lyndon Ravare rec 5 of 56 (9%) · rec yds med 19 | NMSU | WR | 75 | Senior | depth |
| Tayden Barnes | NMSU | FS | 75 | Junior | depth |
| Terrell Washington Jr. pts/play 0.28 · carries 23 of 123 (19%) · rec 5 of 79 (6%) · rush yds med 30 · rec yds med 19 | NMSU | HB | 75 | Junior | depth |
| Brodie Malone-Bradford | NMSU | WR | 74 | Sophomore | depth |
| Henry Davis III | NMSU | DT | 74 | Senior | starter |
| Jerry Lydiatt rec 2 of 42 (5%) · rec yds med 3 | NMSU | TE | 74 | Junior | depth |
| Josiah Jackson | NMSU | DT | 74 | Senior | depth |
| Ma'Kyi Lee | NMSU | LT | 74 | Senior | starter |
| Myles Libman pts/play 0.65 · rec 5 of 42 (12%) · rec yds med 36 | NMSU | WR | 74 | Junior | starter |
| Tyler Keinath | NMSU | RG | 74 | Senior | starter |
| James Williams | NMSU | C | 73 | Junior | starter |
| Xavier Rucker | NMSU | HB | 73 | Freshman | depth |
| De'Marcus Peters | NMSU | CB | 73 ▲5 | Senior | starter |
| Justin Guy | NMSU | CB | 72 (launch) | Sophomore | depth |
| AJ Williams III pts/play 0.89 · rec 8 of 56 (14%) · rec yds med 29 | NMSU | WR | 72 ▲1 | Junior | starter |
| Trey Hedden pts/play 0.23 · carries 17 of 123 (14%) · rush yds med -6 · pass yds med 255 | NMSU | QB | 72 ▲1 | Junior | starter |
| Antoine Bozeman | NMSU | WR | 71 (launch) | Junior | depth |
| David Barker | NMSU | P | 71 | Freshman | depth |
| Izzy Clark-White | NMSU | CB | 71 | Junior | depth |
| JaDarius Sanders | NMSU | WR | 71 | Freshman | depth |
| Joshua Goines | NMSU | TE | 71 | Junior | depth |
| Obinna Okeke rec 2 of 33 (6%) · rec yds med 17 | NMSU | RE | 71 | Junior | depth |
| Luke Moise | NMSU | LG | 71 ▲4 | Junior | depth |
| Mateo Rodriguez | NMSU | LG | 70 ▼1 | Sophomore | starter |
| Derek Widmer | NMSU | RE | 70 (launch) | Senior | depth |
| Enzo-Pierre Tayou | NMSU | DT | 70 | Senior | depth |
| Mark Chapman | NMSU | C | 70 | Senior | depth |
| David Barela | NMSU | HB | 69 | Junior | depth |
| Ilya Uvaydov | NMSU | K | 69 | Senior | depth |
| Jamaun Thompson | NMSU | RE | 69 | Freshman | depth |
| Jordan-Lebron Downey | NMSU | DT | 69 | Junior | depth |
| RJ Chapman | NMSU | FS | 69 | Senior | starter |
| Roscoe Burton | NMSU | HB | 69 | Senior | depth |
| Adam Damante pts/play 0.46 · carries 4 of 71 (6%) · rush yds med 5 · pass yds med 100 | NMSU | QB | 68 | Junior | depth |
| Amaurey Brooks | NMSU | CB | 68 | Sophomore | depth |
| Armond Owens | NMSU | RT | 68 | Junior | starter |
| Carson Su'esu'e rec 1 of 23 (4%) · rec yds med 7 | NMSU | TE | 68 | Freshman | depth |
| Jalen Brown carries 4 of 92 (4%) · rush yds med 12 | NMSU | HB | 68 | Junior | depth |
| Jason Gwan | NMSU | DT | 68 | Junior | depth |
| Javon Gillespie | NMSU | CB | 68 | Junior | starter |
| Jeremiah Sandiford | NMSU | DT | 68 | Senior | depth |
| Kyah Francone | NMSU | K | 68 | Freshman | depth |
| Terrione Graves rec 2 of 37 (5%) · rec yds med 49 | NMSU | WR | 68 | Junior | depth |
| Braydyn Sage | NMSU | TE | 67 | Freshman | depth |
| Demanuel Brown | NMSU | LE | 67 | Junior | depth |
| Evan Blaettler | NMSU | RG | 67 | Junior | depth |
| Jakobe Campbell | NMSU | SS | 67 | Sophomore | depth |
| Joey Banegas | NMSU | RE | 67 | Senior | depth |
| Maxwell Beason | NMSU | RT | 67 (launch) | Sophomore | depth |
| Merrick Becerra | NMSU | LT | 67 | Sophomore | depth |
| Parker Stofa | NMSU | QB | 67 | Sophomore | depth |
| Ray Lotten | NMSU | TE | 67 | Junior | depth |
| Walter Owens | NMSU | FS | 67 | Junior | depth |
| Bradley Vislisel | NMSU | RE | 66 | Junior | depth |
| Desmin Hatfield-Rushton | NMSU | CB | 66 | Junior | depth |
| DJ Cloyd | NMSU | SS | 65 | Senior | depth |
| Duke Frye | NMSU | TE | 65 | Senior | depth |
| Gavin Jones | NMSU | RG | 65 | Freshman | depth |
| Reeves Baller | NMSU | RE | 65 | Junior | depth |
| Sam Garcia | NMSU | LG | 65 ▲2 | Freshman | depth |
| Chance Barron | NMSU | MLB | 64 | Junior | starter |
| Faapaia Fualema | NMSU | MLB | 64 | Junior | depth |
| Garrett Stennett | NMSU | FS | 64 | Freshman | depth |
| Jaylyn Manning | NMSU | ROLB | 64 | Freshman | depth |
| Hayden Harlan | NMSU | C | 63 | Senior | depth |
| Izeyah Wright | NMSU | WR | 63 | Sophomore | depth |
| Kalani Mcleod | NMSU | QB | 62 | Sophomore | depth |
| Nathan Wallin | NMSU | ROLB | 62 | Junior | depth |
| Raylon Carter | NMSU | LE | 62 | Freshman | depth |
| Braxton May | NMSU | TE | 60 (launch) | Sophomore | depth |
| Zaiden Davis | NMSU | ROLB | 60 | Sophomore | depth |
| Drake Williams | NMSU | MLB | 58 | Freshman | depth |
| Josiah Thomas | NMSU | TE | n/r | SO | starter |
| TJ Washington Jr. | NMSU | RB | n/r | SR | starter |
| Brad Vislisel | NMSU | DL | n/r | SR | starter |
| Brad Vislisel | NMSU | DL | n/r | SR | starter |